By: Riley McGuire
With 207 points in 381 games Jordan Staal has already made quite a name for himself in the NHL. He has been to the cup finals twice and even has his name on Lord Stanley’s ultimate prize.
Staal currently has a career high of 49 points (in 08-09, 09-10). On paper all of these statistics and accomplishments sound wonderful, but I believe it is safe to say, Jordan Staal has been one of the biggest disappointments in the 2006 NHL Draft.
Coming into the 2006 NHL draft, Staal was projected to be a very similar player to his brother Eric, with a slightly less offensive touch and a better defensive prowess. With Pittsburgh loaded at center (with a developing Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin) Staal was relegated to third line duties and had an extremely successful with 29 goals including 7 shorthanded markers.
With major hype surrounding Jordan Staal in his sophomore season he fell extremely flat scoring a grand total of 28 points which is a monumental failure of a season. When comparing his rookie year and sophomore season, Staal scored more goals in his first year than points in his second.
With almost identical seasons in year three and four (49 points), Staal hadn’t ballooned into his start of his prime, at least as fast as his brother Eric did. In his 5th season Jordan had a decent start (30 points in 42 games) but injuries knocked him out for the rest of the year. This season Jordan has been playing very good (compared to his previous statistics) and has 9 points, which includes six goals but is already battling injury problems.
Drafted second overall, I thought it would be fun to compare Jordan to those who, in my opinion have been more successful in his draft class;
- Niklas Backstrom – 89 goals, 335 points in 332 games.
- Johnathan Toews – 119 goals, 274 points in 313 games.
- Erik Johnson – 23 goals, 107 points in 236 games.
- Phil Kessel – 138 points, 263 points in 385 games.
- Claude Giroux – 57 goals, 165 points in 219 games.
- Milan Lucic – 67 goals, 158 points in 288 games.
- Jordan Staal – 101 goals, 207 points in 381 games.
There are also other players that can be argued to be in above or the same class as Staal such as Nikolai Kulemin, Chris Stewart and Steve Mason.
All in all, considering his incredible inconsistency and not having a breakthrough year Staal has been (at least in a position) somewhat a bust.

